A method for determining the operational stability of tainter gates has been developed. The authors propose that this method be used to identify potential instabilities of operating gates and that it become a standard acceptance test upon completion of all new gate construction.
By Keiko Anami, Noriaki Ishii, Charles W. Knisely, Takuma Tsuji and Tatsuya Oku
This article has been evaluated and edited in accordance with reviews conducted by two or more professionals who have relevant expertise. These peer reviewers judge manuscripts for technical accuracy, usefulness, and overall importance within the hydroelectric industry.
Tainter gates are used on dams worldwide for regulation and flood release. Frequently, tainter gates cannot be operated at small openings (less than about 5% of submergence depth) due to concerns about self-excited vibrations. In addition, these gates occasionally fail. For example, in 1967, a tainter gate at Wachi Dam in Kyoto prefecture in Japan failed at a small opening and was swept downstream.1,2 Another tainter gate failure occurred on July 17, l995, at Folsom Dam, California in the USA, possibly due to flow-induced vibrations.3
To determine how to prevent such gate failures, the authors have pursued a research program that involves laboratory testing of two- and three-dimensional model gates,4,5 full-scale field tests on operational gates,6,7 and theoretical analyses.8,9 The conclusion was that the underlying mechanism behind the failure of the gates at Wachi and Folsom dams was an essential dynamic instability to which all tainter gates may be susceptible.10 It is imperative to identify susceptible gates and take measures to prevent their failure. In 1991, the number of large dams worldwide approached 35,000; tainter gates are the most common spillway gate, with multiple gates at many of these dams.11
This article presents a method of excitation of tainter gates, analogous to impact testing of smaller structures, that permits identification of the dynamic characteristics, which are indicative of the gates’ potential for dynamic instability.
Mechanisms of coupled-mode self-excited vibration
Tainter gate dynamics can be characterized by two predominant in-air natural vibration modes: the rigid body torsional vibration of the whole gate around the trunnion pin and a streamwise bending vibration mode of the skinplate.3,12 With the gate exposed to flowing water, these two vibration modes can couple through inertial and hydrodynamic forces.12 This coupled-mode vibration is accompanied by a fluctuation in the gate’s discharge and is capable of inducing violent, destructive self-excited vibrations.
If random excitation triggers streamwise vibration of the skinplate, the resulting inertial torque excites the whole gate motion around the trunnion pin, which produces a flow-rate variation and an accompanying pressure fluctuation. If the bottom end of the skinplate behaves as a press-shut device (that is, reduced gate opening with increased upstream head), the flow-rate-variation pressure feeds energy back to the skinplate streamwise vibration, thus increasing its amplitude, which in turn amplifies the torsional vibration around the trunnion pin. This type of coupled-mode self-excited vibration can occur naturally, even if the skinplate is concentric with the trunnion pin.
Of special note is that the streamwise skinplate vibration induces a push-and-draw pressure, which does not consume energy from the vibrating gate but results in a large added mass effect that reduces the frequency of the in-air streamwise skinplate vibration mode in flowing water, often coming dangerously close to the rigid body rotational frequency. If the two frequencies coalesce, the comparatively small amplitude flow-rate-variation pressure can spontaneously amplify the coupled-mode vibration.
For the whole gate rigid-body vibration around the trunnion pin, this coupled-mode self-excited vibration can be represented by:
– Î¸ is the reduced vibration amplitude of the skinplate center;
– Ïˆ is the reduced vibration amplitude of the whole gate around the trunnion pin.
– Î¾aÎ¸ is the in-air damping ratio of rotational vibration around trunnion pin;
– Î±I’ is the non-dimensional moment of inertia; and
– Î±* is the vibration angular amplitude ratio.
For the in-water streamwise vibration of the skinplate, this coupled-mode vibration can be represented by:
– Î¾aÏˆ is streamwise rotational vibration’s in-air damping ratio;
– Î±Ïˆ is the water-to-skinplate mass ratio;
– Î”mÎ¸*, Î”mÏˆ* are the reduced added mass by q and y vibrations;
– Î³ÏˆÎ¸ is the in-air vibration frequency ratio;
– Î¾fÏˆ is the wave-radiation damping ratio;
– Î´p is the pressure correction coefficient;
– Î±IÏˆ is the non-dimensional moment of inertia;
– cf is the instantaneous flow-rate variation coefficient;
– rsa is the non-dimensional rotation radius; and
– FaÎ¸ is the basic Froude number.
Hydrodynamic pressure is absent from Equation 1 because the whole gate rigid-body vibration is excited by the inertia torque of the skinplate. In Equation 2, the first term on the right side represents the energy source that excites the streamwise vibration due to flow-rate variation under the gate.13 The dynamic stability diagram for the gate can be determined by simultaneously solving Equations 1 and 2, using numerical computer simulation.
This fundamental mechanism also applies to streamwise parallel vibration of the skinplate. The resulting inertial force induces a torque around the trunnion pin. This inertia torque, in turn, drives the whole gate vibration around the trunnion pin.
Steel rod breaking excitation method
Identification of the in-air and in-water natural vibration characteristics is essential in ascertaining the dynamic stability of tainter gates. In-air characteristics can be determined by experimental modal analysis using an impact hammer. In water, however, the energy that can be input with an impact hammer is insufficient because of the water’s large added mass. Instead, the tensile failure of a machined steel rod was used to input sufficient energy to excite the relevant mode shapes and provide accurate, repeatable data.
A small-diameter machined steel rod was installed between the bottom center of the skinplate and the spillway concrete. The gate was gradually raised in a step-wise fashion until the rod was loaded past its capacity and broke.
The diameter of the machined portion of the rod is critical to the method. If the diameter is too small, the impulsive load is insufficient to excite the vibration; if it is too large, too much excitation is provided to the gate and lifting system. The diameter was determined using the elongation-to-tension-load characteristics of the gate lifting chains. Based on our experience, elongation of the lifting wires/chains due to the load of the steel rod resistance should not exceed about 1 mm.
For correct testing, it was essential that the operator stop raising the gate immediately when the steel rod breaks. A load cell was attached in series with the steel rod to measure the tension load.
Field vibration test and dynamic stability analysis
Field vibration tests with the steel rod breaking excitation were undertaken on 24-ton and 77-ton tainter gates in the USA, as well as 40- and 73-ton tainter gates in Japan. As an example, test results and the dynamic stability analysis of the 24-ton tainter gate, denoted as Gate T, in the USA is presented.6 The upstream water level at the tested condition was close to maximum design level.
Figure 1 shows the acceleration responses at the skinplate center position, triggered by sudden failure of the steel rod. Figure 1a shows the real-time waveforms of the acceleration response in the tangential direction at the skinplate bottom center, triggered by sudden failure of an 8 mm-diameter steel rod. The exponentially decaying vibration is evident. Figures 1b, 1c and 1d show the frequency power spectrum of the vertical direction acceleration at the bottom center of the skinplate, triggered by sudden failure of 3 mm-diameter, 6 mm-diameter, and 8 mm-diameter steel rods, respectively. There are peaks at 5.5 Hz and at 6.5 Hz that are significant when considering movement-induced self-excitation.
Figure 2 on page 38 shows the mode shapes extracted from the modal testing. Figure 2a shows the mode shape of the skinplate streamwise vibration with a frequency of 5.5 Hz. Based on the modal analysis, the whole skinplate performs a streamwise “parallel vibration” in the press-shut direction (when the skinplate moves in the downstream direction, the whole gate moves downward). The damping ratio estimated from the power spectra using the half-power method takes a comparatively large value of 0.016 to 0.03. Figures 2b and 2c show two vibration modes with a frequency of 6.5 Hz. The skinplate undergoes streamwise rotational vibration in Figure 2b while vibrating in the tangential direction in Figure 2c at the same time, suggesting a streamwise rotational vibration coupled with a vertical vibration.
The streamwise rotation center height is about 2 m from the bottom of the skinplate. The damping ratios take on values of 0.011 to 0.015. These damping ratios do not including Coulomb damping.
Comparison of steel rod breaking and ambient excitation
Ambient excitation tests were conducted on Gate T to assess their suitability in identifying the gate’s natural vibration characteristics. The acceleration power spectra, shown in Figures 1e and 1f, and measured at gate openings of 23 mm and 156 mm, respectively, show many higher frequency components in the 15 Hz to 40 Hz range. The spectra contain no significant peaks near frequencies that can be identified as modes of gate vibration from dynamic analysis. Therefore, it appears impossible to identify the in-water natural vibration frequencies for the dynamic stability analysis of the gate using ambient excitation.
Dynamic stability analysis
Gate T can undergo two coupled mode vibrations:
– Coupling of the skinplate streamwise parallel vibration MX1 (Î©wx = 5.5 Hz) with a whole gate rigid-body rotational vibration around trunnion pin MZ (Î©aÎ¸ = 6.5 Hz); and
– Coupling of the skinplate streamwise rotational vibration MX2 (Î©wÏˆ = 6.5 Hz) with a whole gate rigid-body rotational vibration around trunnion pin MZ (Î©aÎ¸ = 6.5 Hz).
The ratio of the in-water streamwise vibration frequency Î©wx, Ïˆ to the in-air whole gate rotational vibration frequency Î©aÎ¸ takes a value of 0.85 for the first possible coupled-mode vibration and 1 for the second coupling possibility.
At the measured values of Î©nwx = 5.5 Hz and Î©aÎ¸ = 6.5 Hz, the frequency ratio is 0.846. In addition, the in-air damping ratio was estimated to be Î¾ax = 0.03 for the skinplate streamwise parallel vibration. The point defined by these two values is plotted as the filled circle in Figure 3a on page 38. The location of the data point just above the stability curve indicates that the strength of the coupling of the parallel vibration mode with the whole gate rotation mode is insufficient to drive the coupled-mode instability, and the gate narrowly escapes instability.
Similar calculations made for the coupling of modes MX2 and MZ produced the dynamic stability diagram shown in Figure 3b. The overall level of dynamic instability is far smaller than that of Figure 3a. The frequencies of Î©nwÏˆ = 6.5 Hz and Î©aÎ¸ = 6.5 Hz result in a frequency ratio of 1. The in-air damping ratio is estimated to be 0.012 for the skinplate streamwise rotational vibration. This data pair is plotted as the filled circle in Figure 3b. The location again indicates a narrow escape from the unstable region.
Based on this analysis, one may conclude that Gate T barely maintained its dynamic stability for the coupling of mode MX1 with MZ and mode MX2 with MZ.
Model experiment of friction-maintained dynamic stability
As explained earlier, the in-water natural vibration characteristics of the tainter gates cannot be determined by ambient excitation. To discuss the essential dynamic stability and instability of the gate, it is necessary to conduct tests with impulsive excitation, such as the steel rod breaking tests.
An appearance of dynamic stability for a tainter gate may be maintained by damping due to Coulomb friction acting on the side seals and trunnion pin. To consider such stability, model experiments were conducted on a 1/21-scale 3D model of the Folsom Dam tainter gate. Based on a previous study,4,13 violent coupled-mode self-excited vibrations are expected when the in-water natural vibration frequency of the skinplate streamwise vibration is slightly smaller than the natural vibration frequency of the whole gate rotational vibration around the trunnion pin. Therefore, the vibration frequencies were adjusted, yielding a frequency ratio of skinplate streamwise natural vibration to whole gate natural vibration of 0.96. An intense dynamic instability was observed (see Figure 4a).
Under this unstable condition, rubber seals were attached to the sides of the skinplate to add Coulomb friction damping to the model gate. When water was discharged from a small gate opening in this state, no vibration occurred, as shown at times before 1 second in Figure 4b. This trace indicates the Coulomb friction maintained the appearance of dynamic stability, although the model gate has an essential dynamic instability. This trace is analogous to the measurement on the full-scale gate with ambient excitation.
Under the same conditions with the rubber seals in place, a weak vertical displacement trigger was introduced to the model gate. The clearly damped waveforms were measured and a sharp peak at the natural vibration frequency was obtained, as shown after 1 second in Figure 4. This is analogous to the measurement state for the steel rod breaking excitation in the full-scale gate.
When the amplitude of the displacement trigger exceeded the threshold value for the Coulomb friction, violent self-excited vibration of the gate possessing this essential coupled-mode dynamic instability was induced (see Figure 4c).
Through use of steel rod breaking excitation, the gates considered here maintained the appearance of dynamic stability due to Coulomb friction. In addition, it was clearly shown that the dynamic characteristics of full-scale gates cannot be accurately identified using ambient excitation.
The authors hope their testing method can become a standard acceptance test upon the completion of construction of all new gate projects and that it can be used as a tool to identify potential instabilities in tainter gate installations to assure the long-term safe operation of these gates.
The authors wish to acknowledge financial support provided by Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science. Field vibration tests on the full-scale tainter gates were made possible through the special consideration, understanding and cooperation of the U.S. Department of Interior’s Bureau of Reclamation, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and several Japanese gate companies. The authors wish to express their sincere appreciation to these people for their contributions to facilitate the testing.
1. Ishii, N., and K. Imaichi, “Dynamic Instability of Tainter-Gates,” in Practical Experiences with Flow-Induced Vibrations, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1980.
2. Ishii, N., et al, “Tainter Gates – Why Some Fail but Many Do Not,” Proceedings of HydroVision International 2011, PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, Okla., USA, 2011.
3. Ishii, N., “Folsom Dam Gate Failure Evaluation and Suggestions,” report submitted to U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, 1995.
4. Anami, K. and N. Ishii, “Model Tests for Non-Eccentricity Dynamic Instability Closely Related to Folsom Dam Tainter-Gate Failure,” Proceedings of ASME Pressure Vessels and Piping Conference, ASME, New York, N.Y., 2003.
5. Anami, K., et al, “Vibration Tests with a 1/13-Scaled 3D Model of Folsom Dam Tainter-Gate and Its Prediction by Theory,” Proceedings of ASME 6th International Symposium on FSI, AE & FIV+N, ASME, New York, N.Y., 2006.
6. Ishii, N., et al, “Field Tests Concerning the Dynamic Stability of Tainter Gates at the “T” Dam,” Proceedings of WaterPower XVI, PennWell Corporation, Tulsa, Okla., USA, 2009.
7. Ishii, N., et al, “Field Vibration Tests Concerning the Dynamic Stability of Tainter Gates at the “P” Dam,” Proceedings of Hydro 2009, 2009.
8. Anami, K., N. Ishii, and C.W. Knisely, “Validation of Theoretical Analysis of Tainter Gate Instability Using Full-Scale Field Tests, Flow Induced Vibration, Vol. 1, 2004.
9. Anami, K., et al, “Field Measurement of Dynamic Instability of a 50-Ton Tainter-Gate,” Proceedings of ASME Pressure Vessels and Piping Division Conference, ASME, New York, N.Y., USA, 2007.
10. Anami, K., “Flow-Induced Coupled-Mode Self Excited Vibration of Large-Scaled Tainter-Gates,” dissertation submitted to Osaka Electro-Communication University, 2002.
11. Wurbs, R.A., and S.T. Purvis, Military Hydrology: Report 20, Reservoir Outflow (RESOUT) Model, Miscellaneous Paper EL-79-6, prepared by Texas A&M Research Foundation, College Station, Texas, 1991.
12. Anami, K. and N. Ishii, “In-Air and In-Water Natural Vibrations of Folsom Dam Radial Gate in California,” in Experimental Mechanics 1, Balkema, 1998.
13. Anami, K. and N. Ishii, “Flow-Induced Dynamic Instability Closely Related to Folsom Dam Tainter-Gate Failure in California,” in Flow-Induced Vibration, Balkema, 2000.
Keiko Anami is an associate professor at Ashikaga Institute of Technology in Japan. Noriaki Ishii is a professor at Osaka Electro-Communication University in Japan. Charles Knisely is a professor at Bucknell University in the USA. Takuma Tsuji is a guest Researcher at Osaka Electro-Communication University. Tatsuya Oku is an engineer with Mayekawa Co. Ltd. in Japan.